I'm going to list the options here as it is going to be neater than listing the options above. Here's the spreadsheet again in case you want to put the proposed values in the spreadsheet:
Option 1: Retains balance while introducing new categories.
G - 2.5 A - 2 DefP - 0.25 PIM - 0.2 SOG - 0.067 PPP - 1 SHP - 1.5 Hit - 0.3 Blk - 0.3 Tk - 0.1
Option 2: Introduce new categories without changing old values. Skews the balance towards offensive categories while decreasing the value of peripheral categories.
G - 3 A - 2 DefP - .3 PIM - .2 SOG - .05 PPP - 1 SHP - 1.5 Hit - .3 BLK - .3 Tk - .05
Option 3: Readjust values to give offensive categories a minor advantage over peripheral categories.
G - 2.5 A - 2 DefP - .2 PIM - .2 SOG - .1 PPP - 1 SHP - 1.5 Hit - .3 BLK - .3 Tk - .1
Option 4: OTHER. Do you not like any of these options?
Post by MIN (Juuso) on Apr 18, 2016 23:30:28 GMT -8
HartfordRDHL:
I don't like any of those options solely on the reason that takeaways is greatly undervalued even at 0.1.
I think it should hold value similar to hits and blocks, and even doing that shouldn't skew overall points too much as the leader in takeaways this year Mark Stone was the only person to average more than 1 takeaway per game.
If you consider how many guys average more than 1 Hit or Block per game you're looking at a HUGE gap between those stats
The following was brought up in the chat a little earlier on, and I wanted to address this in case other people are having similar thoughts.
The reason to limit takeaways to 0.1 FPts was a conscious decision. There are two main reasons we did this:
1) Takeaways skew the stats in the favour of forwards (in the top 30 skaters ranked according to takeaways, there are only 4 defenseman). If we were to give more FPts to takeaways, we would need to do something to balance defensive categories. Currently the only defensive categories we have are blocks and defenseman points, which would both need to increase in value to compensate an increase in takeaways beyond 0.1 FPts.
2) Takeaways are not really a 'standalone category'. Unlike hits, PIMs or blocks which are not correlated to scoring categories, takeaways are. The vast majority of players who benefit from takeaways will therefore already be rostered, as they are fantasy relevant players. To illustrate this point, here are the free agents in the top 200 skaters ranked according to takeaways:
8 - Grabner, Michael 106 - Fleischmann, Tomas 138 - Stajan, Matt 167 - McClement, Jay 192 - Sceviour, Colton 193 - Fehr, Eric
There are only 6 players who are currently not rostered in the top 200 players ranked by takeaways. Michael Grabner is the only free agent would would stand to see a notable increase in value.
At the end of the day, takeaways are not a great fantasy category. I think there's a reason why they're not more common in fantasy formats.